There’s an age-old debate that seems to divide humanity as much as pineapple on pizza: are you a dog person or a cat person? While both sides share a love for animals, they tend to gravitate toward very different kinds of relationships with their pets. In Ireland, where pet ownership continues to rise in both urban and rural areas, the distinction between dog lovers and cat lovers is becoming more than a lighthearted label—it’s often a reflection of lifestyle, personality, and even how people experience companionship.
So, what does your pet preference say about you? And is it possible you might actually be a little of both?
The Loyal Dog Person
Dog people are often described as outgoing, active, and social. There’s a reason for that: dogs require engagement. You take them out for walks, to the park, on road trips. You talk to strangers because your dog insists on sniffing their dog. Dog ownership pulls you out into the world, whether you planned it or not.
People who choose dogs as their preferred companions often enjoy routine, structure, and shared activity. They don’t mind being greeted at the door like a returning war hero or having a furry shadow follow them from room to room. In fact, they thrive on it.
Dog lovers are generally viewed as extroverts—but that doesn’t mean they’re loud or attention-seeking. It means they value presence, responsiveness, and mutual participation in daily life. Dogs mirror those needs, offering loyalty, energy, and a constant sense of “we’re in this together.”
If this sounds like you, it might be time to find your perfect dog in Ireland.
The Independent Cat Person
Cat lovers, by contrast, are often seen as introspective, thoughtful, and selectively social. Cats don’t perform affection on command—they offer it as a quiet gift, and only when they feel safe. This appeals to people who value boundaries and subtle forms of connection.
Cat people are often comfortable in their own company and value calm, personal space. They don’t need constant noise or external validation to enjoy their day. A cat’s presence is comforting, but not demanding. It’s less about command and more about consent.
This doesn’t mean cat lovers are antisocial—it means they prefer relationships that allow for personal space and respect. Cats reflect that energy. They observe, adapt, and coexist in a way that can feel deeply intimate without being overwhelming.
If you’re more of a calm, quiet thinker than a constant mover, you might want to browse available cats near you and see who’s out there waiting.
Urban vs Rural Realities
In Ireland, your environment can strongly influence which pet is more practical. Urban apartments may not have the space or outdoor access that many dog breeds need, making cats a more convenient choice. Their litter box lifestyle and quiet nature fit easily into city routines.
In contrast, rural or suburban areas offer more freedom and space—perfect for dogs who need to run, explore, and bark without angry neighbours complaining. For families with gardens or open fields nearby, dogs are often the obvious choice.
That said, the rise of dog-friendly apartments, indoor-friendly breeds, and enriched indoor cat setups are challenging these old norms. It’s no longer a question of where you live—it’s how well you adapt your environment to your pet.
The Myth of Mutual Exclusivity
Here’s a secret: plenty of people love both cats and dogs. The so-called “versatile pet person” appreciates the contrast between them—the affectionate loyalty of dogs and the calm intelligence of cats. They might have grown up with both, or simply enjoy the balance that each animal brings to the home.
In fact, many households in Ireland successfully raise cats and dogs together. It takes patience, proper introductions, and a bit of mutual training—but it’s entirely doable. The idea that you have to choose a side is outdated. You can love belly rubs and slow blinks.
So… Which One Are You?
There’s no right answer. Your choice of pet says something about your rhythm, your needs, your style of affection—but it doesn’t define your worth. Whether you find joy in long walks with a goofy retriever or quiet evenings with a purring tabby, the important thing is connection.
Pets bring us back to ourselves. They teach us patience, presence, and empathy. Whether that lesson comes with muddy paw prints or a hair-covered jumper is up to you.
And if you’re still unsure, that’s okay too. The best way to figure it out? Spend time with both. Visit a friend with a cat. Dog-sit for a neighbour. Or simply browse listings and see who tugs at your heart first.
Still Torn Between the Two?
If you’re stuck between the wagging tail and the contented purr, you’re not alone. Sometimes, the question isn’t “dog or cat?” but rather, “which connection feels right—right now?”
Think about what your daily life looks like, what kind of relationship you want to build, and how much time you can give. A dog might challenge you to get outside more, create structure, and laugh daily. A cat might teach you to slow down, pay attention, and appreciate quiet connection.
And remember—you’re not choosing a category, you’re welcoming a companion.
Maybe you’re a dog person.
Maybe a cat person.
Maybe you’re simply a pet person.
And that’s more than enough.
Lynn Martelli is an editor at Readability. She received her MFA in Creative Writing from Antioch University and has worked as an editor for over 10 years. Lynn has edited a wide variety of books, including fiction, non-fiction, memoirs, and more. In her free time, Lynn enjoys reading, writing, and spending time with her family and friends.
